4 Proven Ways to Know When Explicit Teaching Works Best

Pedagogy · Instructional Choices

4 Proven Ways to Know When Explicit Teaching Works Best

Explicit teaching or inquiry? The research says the answer sits with your students, in what they already know.
⏱ 5 min read · By Matt Faulkner · Pedagogy / New Teachers

Few staffroom arguments run hotter than explicit teaching versus inquiry. One camp says tell them first. The other says let them wrestle with the problem. Both camps point to research, and both sound sure of themselves.

The research tells a less tribal story. The same lesson design helps one group of students and holds another back. What decides the outcome is how much your students already know about the content in front of them.

So change the question. Ask which approach fits these students, on this content, today. Below are four ways to make that call.

A teacher guides a small group of primary students as they fold paper fraction strips, an explicit teaching moment before students explore on their own.


Why One Lesson Helps Some Students and Stalls Others

Working memory handles only a few new pieces of information at once. Long-term memory has no such limit. When students already know the building blocks, each block works as a single chunk, which frees space for thinking.

Researchers call the flip side the expertise reversal effect (Kalyuga et al., 2003). Support that helps a novice becomes clutter for a student who knows the content. For example, a worked example rescues a beginner. A confident student has to wade through the same example to reach the bit they need.

As a result, no single approach suits every student or every topic. The variable worth watching is prior knowledge, and you can check it in minutes.


1. Check What They Know Before You Choose

A prior knowledge check is not a pre-test. Two minutes at the start of a lesson tells you plenty. In practice, it works like any other piece of formative assessment: you gather evidence, then you act on it.

🔍 Two-Minute Prior Knowledge Checks
  • One entry question on mini whiteboards. Scan the room in 10 seconds.
  • Show, hide, rebuild. Show a diagram or rule for five seconds, hide it, then ask students to reproduce it.
  • Example or non-example. Hold up four cases and ask students to sort them.
  • Partner explain. Pairs explain the idea to each other while you listen in on three of them.

Expect a spread. Most checks reveal two or three groups rather than one tidy class, and that spread shapes everything that follows.


2. Use Explicit Teaching When the Parts Are New and Connected

Some content has many parts that depend on each other. Researchers call this high element interactivity. A student can’t understand one piece without holding several others in mind at the same time.

Ashman, Kalyuga and Sweller (2020) tested this with Year 5 students learning about light energy efficiency. In the first experiment, with simpler material, explaining first gave better results on practice-style problems. Transfer showed no difference. Then the researchers made the material more complex. This time, explaining first won on both practice and transfer problems.

That fits a longer line of research on novices. Kirschner, Sweller and Clark (2006) argued that beginners learn more from full guidance than from discovery. Discovery overloads their working memory.

Here’s a maths version. Picture Year 3 students meeting equivalent fractions for the first time. A teacher models with fraction strips and talks through one worked example. Students then try a few with support before working alone.


3. Let Students Explore First When the Building Blocks Are Secure

Zhang and Sweller (2024) studied 85 middle school students learning about density. The students who knew less did better when the teacher explained first. The students who knew more did better when they investigated first. Same content, opposite winners.

Supporters of productive failure go further. Kapur (2016) argues that struggling with a problem before instruction helps students notice what they don’t know yet. Productive failure is a specific form of productive struggle, timed before the teaching instead of after it. That said, struggle pays off when students have something to struggle with. Our post on making students struggle productively covers how to set that up.

Back to the fractions lesson. Students who already know halves and quarters don’t need the worked example. Instead, hand them a strip and a challenge. How many fractions equal to one half can they fold? Afterwards, name the pattern explicitly with the whole group.

Your best starting point depends less on your teaching philosophy than on what students walked in knowing.
🧭 Explain First or Explore First?
  • Explain first when the content is new, the parts depend on each other, or early errors would stick.
  • Explain first when your prior knowledge check shows gaps in the building blocks.
  • Explore first when students hold the building blocks and the task asks them to connect known ideas.
  • Explore first only if you plan to consolidate explicitly afterwards. Investigation without a debrief leaves misconceptions in place.

4. Shift Your Approach as Their Knowledge Grows

Today’s explain-first lesson becomes next week’s explore-first lesson. In other words, the content stays the same while your students change. That’s gradual release working across a sequence, and it’s the same thinking behind fading support across lessons.

Watch for the moment to hand over. Our post on the signs it’s time to fade the scaffold lists what to look for. Even so, the path isn’t one-way. If errors creep back in, bring the explicit support back for a lesson.

One honest caveat. The research debate isn’t settled, and most of these studies ran over a session or two. Productive failure researchers also point out a weakness. Many studies favouring explicit teaching compare it against unguided struggle, a weak opponent. At the same time, the pattern across studies is consistent enough to act on. Novices need guidance first, and students with secure knowledge benefit from more room.

Next week we start a three-part series on cognitive load theory, the thinking that sits underneath all of this.

Over to you

What’s your default when you introduce something new: explain first or explore first? Think of a lesson where the other approach would have served your students better. Tell us about it in the comments.

References

Ashman, G., Kalyuga, S., & Sweller, J. (2020). Problem-solving or explicit instruction: Which should go first when element interactivity is high? Educational Psychology Review, 32(1), 229–247. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-019-09500-5

Kalyuga, S., Ayres, P., Chandler, P., & Sweller, J. (2003). The expertise reversal effect. Educational Psychologist, 38(1), 23–31. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15326985EP3801_4

Kapur, M. (2016). Examining productive failure, productive success, unproductive failure, and unproductive success in learning. Educational Psychologist, 51(2), 289–299. https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2016.1155457

Kirschner, P. A., Sweller, J., & Clark, R. E. (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching. Educational Psychologist, 41(2), 75–86. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15326985ep4102_1

Zhang, L., & Sweller, J. (2024). Instructional sequences in science teaching: Considering element interactivity when sequencing inquiry-based investigation activities and explicit instruction. European Journal of Psychology of Education, 39(4), 3791–3801. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10212-024-00799-5

5 Proven Ways to Spot AI Shortcuts That Cost Learning

Teaching in the Digital Age · Keep the Thinking Human (Part 1)

5 Proven Ways to Spot AI Shortcuts That Cost Learning

The riskiest AI shortcuts look harmless. They skip the exact thinking the task was built to teach.
⏱ 6 min read · By Matt Faulkner · Pedagogy / Gen AI

A Year 5 student is stuck on a narrative. She asks an AI tool for story ideas and gets 20 in four seconds. She picks one, writes it up, and hands it in. Nobody cheated. The AI never wrote a word of her story.

So what was lost? The answer is the part of the lesson that mattered most. Generating ideas, sorting weak ones from strong ones, and backing a choice is the skill. Those quiet AI shortcuts rarely look like cheating, which is why they slip past us.

This post opens a three-part series called Keep the Thinking Human. Part 1 names five common AI uses that feel safe but cost learning. Part 2 shows how to set clear AI rules task by task. Part 3 covers how to see student thinking without playing detective.

A Year 5 student scrolls AI story ideas on a tablet while classmates sort their own sticky-note ideas, showing how AI shortcuts skip the thinking.


The One Test Behind Every AI Shortcut

Cognitive scientist Daniel Willingham offers a simple filter. Most school AI policies treat the student as the lead and AI as the assistant. That works in a workplace, where the product is the point. In a classroom, the product is rarely the point.

Nobody needs another Year 4 information report about frogs. We set the task because writing it builds thinking we care about. For that reason, Willingham suggests one question before any AI use. Is doing this part yourself still part of what you need to learn?

If the answer is yes, AI is taking the learning, not saving time. With that test in mind, here are five AI shortcuts that fail it more often than they pass.


Shortcut 1: Brainstorming With AI

Brainstorming looks like the safest job to hand over. In fact, the research is mixed in a way worth knowing. Doshi and Hauser (2024) found writers given AI ideas produced stories judged more creative. Even so, those stories were more alike than stories written without AI.

A 2025 study by Zhou and colleagues followed what happened next. Participants did better on creative tasks while they had ChatGPT. Once the tool was removed, their creativity dropped away. Their ideas also kept getting more alike for months afterwards. The researchers called this a creative scar.

In practice, keep the messy first round human. Give pairs three minutes and a sticky-note goal of 10 ideas. Bad ideas count. The sorting that follows is where children learn what makes an idea strong.

Shortcut 2: Letting AI Find the Main Idea

Secondary teachers call it the thesis. In primary, it is the topic sentence or the main idea of a paragraph. Either way, it is the sentence a student has to think hardest to write.

High school English teacher Chanea Bond let her students choose. They could write their own thesis or feed their notes to AI for one. The students who used AI wrote weak essays. They lacked the skills to turn AI output into something worth reading.

For example, a Year 4 student writing about echidnas needs to decide what matters most. That decision is the learning. A main idea handed to them skips it, and the paragraphs that follow show it.


Shortcut 3: Using AI to Do the Research

Research is where AI feels most like a librarian. In reality, it often pulls from whatever pages it finds and presents them with equal confidence. For a student still learning to judge sources, every answer looks equally solid.

The bigger loss is the skill itself. Choosing a source, checking it and comparing two of them is what research teaches. We covered how to teach students to catch AI mistakes earlier this term. That only works once students know how to check a claim without the tool.

A useful middle ground comes from Benjamin Barbour, a US high school teacher and librarian. His students may use AI to find weak spots in their own plan. They must still talk fluently about their research to an audience. That expectation keeps the learning with the student.

Shortcut 4: Reading an AI Summary

Students love a tidy summary. A photo of their notes becomes a neat page of dot points in seconds. Even so, reading a summary is passive, and it gives students a false sense that they understand.

The evidence for doing it yourself is strong. Lawson and Mayer (2021) compared students who wrote their own explanation with students who read one. On a delayed test, the writers did better. Writing the explanation forces students to pull ideas from memory and reorganise them.

In other words, the summary is not the goal. The act of making it is. A two-minute “write what you remember” before students check their notes does far more than any polished AI summary.


Shortcut 5: Starting From an AI First Draft

The blank page is hard, so an AI first draft feels kind. The evidence says otherwise. Bastani and colleagues (2025) gave nearly 1,000 high school maths students access to GPT-4 during practice. Their practice scores rose by 48%.

Then the researchers removed access for the exam. Those students scored 17% lower than peers who never had AI. Students had used it as a crutch. By contrast, a tutor version that gave hints instead of answers largely avoided the drop.

Students using AI looked better at practice and turned out worse at the test. That gap is the cost of a shortcut.

Writing works the same way. A first draft is where a student finds out what they think. Hand that over, and the student edits someone else’s thinking instead of building their own. This links straight back to designing for productive struggle.


How to Check Any Task for AI Shortcuts

None of this means AI has no place in your room. It means the job you give it matters. Before any task, run it past the questions below.

🔍 The AI Shortcut Check
  • What skill is this task for? Name it in one sentence before deciding anything else.
  • Which step builds that skill? Brainstorming, choosing, drafting or explaining are the usual suspects.
  • Would AI do that step for them? If yes, keep AI out of that step.
  • Can they already do it well? If a student has mastered the step, AI help costs far less.
  • Will you see their thinking? If the only evidence is the product, plan a way to see the process.

Most students will not choose the harder path on their own, and that is human nature, not laziness. That is why the decision sits with us. As we saw with fake engagement, a finished product can hide shallow thinking.

Next week, Part 2 turns the check into a routine. We look at how to set clear AI rules for each task. We also cover how to explain them so students follow the logic.

Your turn

Which of these five AI shortcuts have you already seen in your classroom? Tell us in the comments, along with one task you plan to keep AI-free this term.

References

Bastani, H., Bastani, O., Sungu, A., Ge, H., Kabakcı, Ö., & Mariman, R. (2025). Generative AI without guardrails can harm learning: Evidence from high school mathematics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(26), e2422633122. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2422633122

Doshi, A. R., & Hauser, O. P. (2024). Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content. Science Advances, 10(28), eadn5290. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adn5290

Lawson, A. P., & Mayer, R. E. (2021). Benefits of writing an explanation during pauses in multimedia lessons. Educational Psychology Review, 33(4), 1859–1885. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-021-09594-w

Tutt, P., & Merrill, S. (2026, October 16). 5 ‘good’ AI use cases that are actually bad for students. Edutopia. edutopia.org

Willingham, D. (2026, August 27). Students should only use AI for things they already know how to do well. Thomas B. Fordham Institute. fordhaminstitute.org

Zhou, Y., Liu, Q., Huang, J., & Li, G. (2025). Creative scar without generative AI: Individual creativity fails to sustain while homogeneity keeps climbing. Technology in Society, 103087. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2025.103087

4 Proven Ways to Build Student Persistence With Stories

Core Pedagogy · Motivation

4 Proven Ways to Build Student Persistence With Stories

Success stories show students what is possible. Struggle stories build student persistence by showing what to do next.
⏱ 6 min read · By Matt Faulkner · Pedagogy / New Teachers

You know the moment. A Year 4 student hits a tricky division problem, the pencil stops and their head drops onto the desk. “I’m not a maths person.”

What happens in the next two minutes decides whether that struggle turns into learning. We have written before about designing tasks for productive struggle. This post tackles the other half. How do you build student persistence so children keep going once the struggle arrives?

Todd Finley’s recent Edutopia piece points to a simple, research-backed tool. Tell students true stories about people who struggled before they succeeded. Done well, struggle stories lift persistence. Done badly, they turn into another poster slogan, much like the general capabilities we looked at last week.

A teacher reads a picture book to a small group while a student uses a When I'm Stuck card to build student persistence in maths.


What the Research Says About Student Persistence

The evidence starts surprisingly young. In a 2022 study, Amanda Haber and colleagues read four- and five-year-olds a storybook about Albert Einstein or Marie Curie. Some versions described the scientist’s intellectual struggles. Others described struggles in their personal life. Then each child faced a puzzle with no solution.

Children who heard a struggle story kept trying for around 74 to 79 seconds. By contrast, children who heard neither struggle story gave up after about 55 seconds. A 2024 follow-up with preschoolers and their caregivers found a similar boost.

Older students respond too. In a well-known 2016 study, Xiaodong Lin-Siegler and her team gave high school students stories about famous scientists.

Students who read about the scientists’ struggles earned better science grades afterwards. In contrast, students who read achievement-only stories saw their grades drop. The effect was small, yet strongest for lower-performing students.

Achievement-only stories tell children success comes naturally. Struggle stories show them what to do when it doesn’t.

Way 1: Choose Stories Students Can See Themselves In

Not every role model works. Gladstone and Cimpian reviewed 55 studies of STEM role models in 2021. The role models who motivated students had three things in common. They were competent, students saw them as similar to themselves, and their success felt within reach.

On the other hand, extreme success can backfire. A child struggling with spelling may feel further away, not closer, after hearing about a Nobel Prize winner. At the same time, role models from under-represented groups had broad positive effects. That held for students of all backgrounds.

In practice, mix the famous with the familiar. A Year 6 student who finally cracked long division. The school gardener who retrained in their 40s. An Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander community member your school already works with. You, learning to play guitar at 35. Familiar faces close the gap between “them” and “me.” That sense of “someone like me” is where student persistence starts.

Two cautions from Finley are worth keeping. Skip the “anyone can do anything” line, because children know it isn’t true. And when poverty or racism shaped someone’s struggle, don’t suggest persistence alone beat it.


Way 2: Name the Move, Not the Trait

“She never gave up” describes a trait. Children can admire a trait, but they can’t copy it. Instead, name the specific move the person made.

For example, picture a Year 5 student who couldn’t learn her times tables by chanting them. So she made her own flashcards and tested her brother at dinner every night. That is a move another child can borrow tomorrow. Borrowed moves like this are the building blocks of student persistence.

The research backs this up. In one 2016 study, students struggled to pick out a role model’s actual strategies. So researchers asked them to write a short learning contract with two actions they would try in class.

A primary version is a “When I’m Stuck” card on each desk. Students add one strategy from each story they hear.

This connects with the mediated learning approach in our Feuerstein and growth mindset post. Effort only becomes useful once a child knows what to do differently.

Way 3: Pause the Story at the Hard Part

Finley suggests the interrupted narrative. Tell the story up to the point where everything goes wrong, then stop. Ask the class what they would try next. Only then reveal what the person did.

That pause turns students from listeners into problem-solvers. As a result, they rehearse the decision before they ever need it. That rehearsal builds student persistence before the hard moment arrives. Most good struggle stories also follow the same shape, so teach students to spot it.

🪜 The Struggle Story Arc
  • Struggle: What went wrong?
  • Analysis: What did they notice about why it went wrong?
  • Strategy: What did they decide to try?
  • Action: What did they do, step by step?
  • Result: What happened, including the parts that still didn’t work?

Way 4: Debrief, Then Hand Over the Struggle

A story without a debrief is entertainment. Finley offers three short questions to use after each one. What did the failed attempt reveal? What did the person change or learn? Which strategy could help with the task we are working on now?

Then comes the step that matters most. A borrowed story can’t replace a child’s own success. Lasting student persistence grows from a child’s own small wins. Follow the story straight away with a task at the right level of challenge. Then give students the support to try the strategy. Our post on fading the scaffold covers how to pull that support back as students grow more confident.

Build Student Persistence in Ten Minutes a Week

You don’t need a new program. One short story a week, told well, builds a class bank of strategies by the end of term. For younger students, picture books work well. Ashley Spires’ The Most Magnificent Thing follows a girl whose invention keeps failing until she steps away and comes back.

💡 A Ten-Minute Struggle Story Routine
  • 2 minutes: Tell the story up to the hard part.
  • 2 minutes: Pairs predict what the person tried next.
  • 2 minutes: Finish the story.
  • 3 minutes: Debrief with the three questions.
  • 1 minute: Each student adds one strategy to their “When I’m Stuck” card.

Your turn

What is your own struggle story, the one your students would never guess? Share it in the comments, along with the move that got you through. It might become someone else’s Monday lesson.

References

Finley, T. (2026, October 1). A research-based strategy for guiding students to engage in productive struggle. Edutopia. edutopia.org

Gladstone, J. R., & Cimpian, A. (2021). Which role models are effective for which students? A systematic review and four recommendations for maximizing the effectiveness of role models in STEM. International Journal of STEM Education, 8, Article 59. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40594-021-00315-x

Haber, A. S., Kumar, S. C., & Corriveau, K. H. (2022). Boosting children’s persistence through scientific storybook reading. Journal of Cognition and Development, 23(2), 161–172. https://doi.org/10.1080/15248372.2021.1998063

Lin-Siegler, X., Ahn, J. N., Chen, J., Fang, F.-F. A., & Luna-Lucero, M. (2016). Even Einstein struggled: Effects of learning about great scientists’ struggles on high school students’ motivation to learn science. Journal of Educational Psychology, 108(3), 314–328.

Spires, A. (2014). The most magnificent thing. Kids Can Press.

4 Easy Ways to Help Students Catch AI Mistakes

Four proven ways to teach primary students to check AI output: plant an error, rerun and compare, ask one question every time, and build knowledge first.

Teaching in the Digital Age · AI Literacy

4 Proven Ways to Spot AI Mistakes in Your Classroom

AI hands your students a confident answer every time. The skill worth teaching is knowing when to doubt it.
⏱ 6 min read · By Matt Faulkner · Pedagogy / Gen AI

Last week’s look at the PISA device myth ended on one finding worth a second look. Students taught to check AI output outperformed students who used AI to write their drafts. Same tool, different job for the student.

That finding raises a practical question. What does it look like to teach a Year 5 class to check AI output on a Tuesday afternoon? Most advice stops at “teach critical thinking.” That gives you a goal, not a lesson.

AJ Juliani’s recent piece, Teach the Frontier, offers a sharper starting point. Every serious plan for keeping AI honest assumes someone has the knowledge and judgement to say “that’s wrong.” By 2040, those people will be the students sitting in your room right now. Here are four ways to start building that judgement in a primary classroom.

Primary students point at an AI answer on the classroom board and check it for errors while their teacher watches.


Way 1: Build Knowledge Before You Check AI Output

Start with the step most AI advice skips. A student has nothing to check an answer against without knowing the topic first.

Daniel Willingham made this case long before chatbots arrived. Critical thinking, he argued, is not a free-floating skill you teach once and apply everywhere. It depends on what you know about the subject in front of you. In other words, a student who thinks critically about fractions might be helpless with a question about volcanoes.

Picture a Year 4 HASS class asking an AI tool about the First Fleet. The answer says the convicts settled at Botany Bay. A student who has studied the unit knows the fleet moved on to Sydney Cove. A student who hasn’t will copy the error into their book, neatly and confidently.

A student only catches a wrong answer about something they already know. Knowledge is the checking tool.

Juliani puts it plainly: judgement sits on top of knowledge. As AI tools get more capable, background knowledge matters more, not less. For this reason, a knowledge-rich unit is your first and best protection against AI errors.


Way 2: Plant an Error, Then Check AI Output

The simplest place to start is an AI answer you have checked yourself. Before the lesson, run a prompt, read the response, and make sure it contains one or two errors. Some will appear on their own. Otherwise, edit one in.

Run the prompt yourself rather than handing students a login. Many AI tools set age limits above primary school. The Australian Framework for Generative AI in Schools also asks schools to protect student data. Displaying the output on the board avoids both problems.

For example, ask an AI tool to explain to a Year 5 student how to compare decimals. Then plant a classic misconception: “0.25 is bigger than 0.5 because 25 is bigger than 5.” Tell the class there are two errors, and give pairs five minutes to find them. The misconception you plant is often the one half the room already holds. As a result, the error hunt doubles as a diagnostic.


Way 3: Rerun the Prompt to Check AI Output

Next, run the same prompt twice and put both answers side by side. Ask students one question: where do these answers disagree?

Disagreement is a signal. If one answer gives a river’s length in one figure and the second gives another, at least one is wrong. Students then go to the atlas, the textbook, or a trusted website to settle it. That trip to a second source is how students learn to check AI output.

Even so, teach the other half of the lesson too. Two AI answers that agree can still both be wrong, because they come from the same tool. Agreement tells you the tool is consistent. Only a source outside the tool tells you it is right.


Way 4: Make One Question a Routine

Juliani asks his own children one question every time AI gives them an answer: “How would you know if it was wrong?” His hope is that one day they ask it without him.

That repetition is the point. A routine question works the same way as the higher-order questioning you already use, except students eventually take it over. It also pushes back on the problem we covered in the AI confidence trap. AI tools tend to agree with the user, so students need a habit of disagreeing with the tool.

🔍 Five Questions for Every AI Answer
  • How would you know if this was wrong? The anchor question. Ask it every time.
  • Where else could you check this? Name a source outside the AI tool.
  • Does this match what we learnt in class? Sends students back to their own knowledge.
  • Which part sounds sure but shows no evidence? Confident tone is not proof.
  • What did it leave out? A harder one for Years 5 and 6.

Print the list as a bookmark or a poster near the board. In practice, the first question carries most of the weight. The other four give older students somewhere to go next.


Keep Most Tasks AI-Free, and Say Why

All four ways share one condition. Students need plenty of work where AI plays no part at all. Juliani’s advice is to keep most tasks AI-free and to tell students the reason. The hard thinking stays with the student, because that thinking builds the knowledge they will later check AI output against.

This links straight back to productive struggle. A student who hands the hard part to a chatbot skips the struggle, and skips the learning with it. Telling them so is honest, and most Year 6 students will follow the logic.

The Framework backs this up. Guiding statement 1.2 asks schools to teach students how AI tools work, including their limitations and biases. Statement 1.4 asks for AI use that supports critical thinking rather than restricting it. Statement 1.5 asks every task to state clearly whether AI belongs in it. The four ways above give you a classroom version of all three.

🗓️ A Four-Week Starter Plan
  • Week 1: Teach the content. No AI. Tell students why.
  • Week 2: Plant two errors in an AI answer on that content and run the hunt.
  • Week 3: Rerun one prompt twice and settle the disagreements with a second source.
  • Week 4: Hand pairs a fresh AI answer and the five questions. Step back and watch.

Your turn

Try the planted-error hunt with your class this term. Which error did your students catch first, and which one slipped past everyone? Tell us in the comments.

References

Australian Government Department of Education. (2023). Australian framework for generative artificial intelligence (AI) in schools. education.gov.au

Juliani, A. J. (2026, September 18). Teach the frontier. Next Gen Schools. ajjuliani.beehiiv.com

Juliani, A. J. (2026, September). What the PISA results really show us about technology and curriculum. AJ Juliani. ajjuliani.com

Willingham, D. T. (2007). Critical thinking: Why is it so hard to teach? American Educator, 31(2), 8–19.

5 Moves That Stop Students Taking the Easy Way Out

 Pedagogy · Cognitive Engagement

Why Your Classroom Might Be Teaching Students to Switch Off

The problem isn’t that students resist thinking. It’s that we’ve made not thinking the easier option.

⏱ 6 min read · By Matt Faulkner · Pedagogy / Cognitive Engagement

The average time a person spends on any single screen before switching has dropped from two and a half minutes in 2004 to around 47 seconds today. That is not a phone problem. That is a habit problem — and schools have been quietly building it for decades.

Last week’s post on productive struggle made the case that genuine learning requires cognitive effort — and that effort is often uncomfortable. That said, naming productive struggle as a goal is the easy part. The harder question is: what force is working against it? Why do students so reliably reach for the path of least cognitive resistance, even when they are sitting in a room designed for learning?

The answer isn’t laziness. In most cases, it isn’t even a lack of motivation. It’s something more structural — and more fixable.


What Is the Path of Least Cognitive Resistance?

The brain is an energy-conservation machine. Left to its own devices, it defaults to the lowest-cost route available. Psychologists call this System 1 thinking — fast, automatic, low-effort. System 2, the slower and more deliberate mode, is what we need for analysis, problem-solving, and genuine learning. The catch is that System 2 is expensive. The brain only commits to it when it has to.

This is not a design flaw. In most areas of life, conserving cognitive energy is sensible. The problem arises when classroom environments are structured in ways that make System 1 sufficient. In other words, when students can get through a lesson — answer the questions, fill the worksheet, satisfy the teacher — without ever really thinking.

The OECD defines cognitive engagement as the mental state where learners exert sufficient, sustained effort to persist with a complex idea or unstructured problem. That definition is worth holding onto. It is specifically about effort and persistence. Not compliance, not busyness, and not the appearance of working. By that definition, a class full of students who are on task may still not be cognitively engaged at all.

A student checking Instagram to survive a pointless lesson is different from a student checking Instagram during a lesson they find meaningful. We tend to treat these as the same problem. They are not.

How Classrooms Create the Problem

Here is the uncomfortable part. Distraction is not just something that happens to learners from the outside. It is also something that learning environments create from the inside.

Compliance-based classrooms — built around predictable tasks, scripted routines, and curricula disconnected from students’ questions — don’t simply fail to engage learners. Over time, they train students to zone out. To wait for class to end. To treat thinking as optional. The path of least cognitive resistance becomes the default setting. Not because students chose it, but because the environment made it easy.

That said, this is different from the phone debate. Removing distractions from the outside — banning devices, adjusting seating — addresses one half of the problem. The other half is internal: the structure of the learning experience itself. A student who finds a lesson genuinely purposeful will resist external distraction far better than one simply going through the motions in a phone-free room.

In practice, this means the question isn’t only “how do I keep students on task?” It is “what is the task asking of them, cognitively?” Those are different questions. Only the second one changes the default.


The Environment Angle: Make Thinking the Easier Choice

Research from UCL suggests that human decisions are shaped not just by deliberate reasoning but by the friction profile of available choices — how easy or effortful each option feels. The implication for classrooms is direct. If passive compliance is frictionless and active thinking requires effort, most students will choose compliance. As a result, the fix isn’t only to motivate students to think harder. It is to reduce the friction on thinking and raise the friction on switching off.

In other words, that’s a design problem — and it has design solutions.

Reducing Friction on Thinking

🏗️ Environment Moves That Shift the Default
  • Change the seating expectation. Rows facing the front make passive reception easy. Clusters or paired arrangements make conversation the default. Neither is always right, but consider what behaviour each layout makes effortless.
  • Build in talk as a structural requirement, not a reward. When discussion is positioned as “time to chat before we get back to work,” students read it as a break. When it is built into the task — “you need a partner’s view to complete this” — thinking becomes the easier path.
  • Use visible thinking tools. Mini whiteboards, sticky notes, and shared documents make thinking visible and public. That slight social pressure — knowing others can see your ideas — raises the cost of switching off.
  • Vary the routine intentionally. Around 45% of everyday behaviours are repeated in the same location without deliberate thought. When every lesson follows the exact same structure, the brain learns to run on autopilot. Small, deliberate variation — a different entry task, a different question format — keeps System 2 online a little longer.

The Planning Angle: Build Demand Into the Task

Environment changes help, but they are only scaffolding. The more powerful lever is the task itself. Even so, a thoughtfully designed environment cannot compensate for a task that requires no thinking.

For that reason, the key question at the planning stage — before you write the lesson, not after — is: at what point in this task does a student have to think? If the answer is “never, really,” the task needs redesigning, not better classroom management. This is exactly the territory that backward design addresses. Start from the learning intention and work backwards to a task that genuinely demands it.

Beyond that, the type of thinking matters. Tasks that ask students to recall, copy, or follow a procedure leave System 2 largely unused. By contrast, tasks that require students to evaluate, connect, justify, or construct something novel pull System 2 into the work. That is the core of what we covered in our post on higher-order questioning — and it applies equally to tasks, not just questions.

Task Design Checks Before You Teach

✏️ Four Planning Questions to Raise Cognitive Demand
  • Can a student complete this without thinking? If the answer is yes — if recall, copying, or pattern-matching is sufficient — redesign the endpoint. Add a “why” or “how do you know” requirement.
  • Does the task have a low floor and a high ceiling? Every student should be able to begin. Not every student should be able to finish quickly. Open-ended tasks with multiple entry points make switching off less tempting because there is always somewhere to go.
  • Where is the decision point? The moment a student must choose — between interpretations, approaches, or ideas — is the moment cognitive effort is unavoidable. Plan at least one genuine decision into every task.
  • Does the task connect to something students actually care about? Relevance reduces the pull of least resistance. Students will do more cognitive work on a problem they find worth solving.

Making Thinking the Low-Resistance Option

The goal is not to make classrooms cognitively exhausting. Students need to build capacity gradually — and they need to feel the success of thinking hard and getting somewhere. That is exactly the territory covered in the productive struggle post: challenge needs to sit within reach.

Even so, the framing shift matters. For most of us, the instinct is to fight the path of least resistance. To push students to try harder, engage more, focus better. That framing puts all the responsibility on the student. A more productive question is: which path are we making easy? In a well-designed classroom, the low-resistance option and the thinking option are, as often as possible, the same thing.

That doesn’t happen by accident. It happens in the planning stage and in the physical arrangement of the room. It happens in the habits we build — deliberately — from the first weeks of the year. Which is, conveniently, what the next series of posts is going to look at.

What does the path of least resistance look like in your classroom? Is it a particular task type, a time of day, or a room setup that makes switching off too easy? Share what you’ve noticed — and what you’ve tried — in the comments below.

References and Further Reading

Juliani, A. J. (2025). We have a distraction problem. But we’ve been solving the wrong half of it. ajjuliani.com. ajjuliani.com

OECD. (2025). Ensuring cognitive engagement: Unlocking high-quality teaching. OECD Publishing. oecd.org

University College London. (2017, February 21). Humans are hard-wired to follow the path of least resistance. ScienceDaily. sciencedaily.com

Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

5 Powerful Moves That Will Actually Make Students Struggle

Week 15 · Pedagogy · Task Design

5 Task Design Moves That Actually Stretch Every Student

Productive struggle isn’t what happens when a task is too hard. It’s what happens when you’ve designed it just right.
⏱ 6 min read · By Matt Faulkner · Pedagogy / New Teachers

There is a particular kind of classroom frustration that has nothing to do with behaviour. It is the lesson where students race through the task, and you realise about twelve minutes in that it asked nothing of them. Or the opposite: where you pitched it harder and now three hands are up, six students are staring at the ceiling, and two have quietly written their name and stopped.

Both of those outcomes have the same root cause. The task was not designed with stretch in mind. It was designed with content in mind — and there is a difference.

Last week, we looked at how backward design changes what you plan for. This post takes the next step. Once you know where students need to get to, the question becomes: how do you design the task that gets them there — one that genuinely challenges without tipping into frustration? The answer has a name in the research literature: productive struggle. And it can be deliberately built in.


What “Just Beyond Comfortable” Actually Means

Lev Vygotsky described the zone of proximal development (ZPD) as the space between what a learner can do independently and what they can do with support. Tasks that sit below the ZPD require no new thinking. Tasks that sit too far above it produce confusion and disengagement. Tasks that sit right at the edge of the ZPD — just beyond what a student can currently do alone — are where genuine learning occurs.

John Sweller’s cognitive load theory adds important precision here. Working memory is limited. When a task overloads it — too many new elements at once, too much unfamiliar vocabulary, too many simultaneous steps — students cannot process the content, let alone learn from it. In other words, difficulty alone is not the goal. Productive difficulty is. The task needs to be complex enough to require real thinking, but structured enough that thinking is actually possible.

For teachers, that distinction is everything. A task is not automatically rigorous because it is hard. It is rigorous when it demands higher-order thinking within a structure students can manage. As a result, designing for productive struggle is less about making tasks harder and more about making them smarter.


The Mindset Piece: Designing for Effort, Not Just Difficulty

Carol Dweck’s research on growth mindset is relevant here — but not in the way it is usually applied. It is not enough to tell students that struggle is good for them. If the task design sends the opposite message — if there is only one right answer, if being wrong feels like failure, if speed is implicitly rewarded — then the growth mindset poster on the wall is just decoration.

Dweck’s central finding is that students who believe intelligence is fixed avoid challenge to protect their self-image. By contrast, students who believe ability grows through effort seek out challenge. The task itself can reinforce either belief. A task with one quick answer rewards speed and confidence. A task that requires iteration, justification, and revision sends the message that effort is the point.

That said, this is not about lowering the stakes or removing rigour. It is about designing tasks where being stuck is a legitimate part of the process — and where the structure supports students to push through, rather than wait for the teacher to rescue them.

There is a timely corollary here for AI use in classrooms. Cognitive scientist Paul Kirschner draws a useful distinction between cognitive offloading and cognitive outsourcing. Offloading — writing notes, drawing a diagram, working through steps on paper — frees up working memory while keeping the student as the thinker. Outsourcing — asking AI to explain, summarise, or produce — transfers the thinking itself to an external agent. The student receives a finished product. Nothing is encoded in long-term memory. For teachers designing tasks with productive struggle in mind, the question is worth asking: does the way students are using AI protect generation, or remove it entirely?


5 Design Moves That Build Productive Struggle In

These moves can be applied individually or in combination. They work across year levels and learning areas. Even one move applied consistently will shift what students experience in your classroom.

🎯 5 Task Design Moves for Productive Struggle
  • Move 1 — Open the entry point. Design tasks with a low floor and a high ceiling. Every student can begin; not every student will reach the same endpoint. This removes the paralysis of “I don’t know where to start” while keeping stretch available for those who are ready for it. Jo Boaler’s work on low-floor/high-ceiling tasks in mathematics is the clearest articulation of this principle in practice — and her YouCubed site has free task banks worth bookmarking.
  • Move 2 — Withhold the scaffold before the answer. Give students the problem before you give them the method. Even five minutes of initial thinking — before any explicit teaching — activates prior knowledge, surfaces misconceptions, and means the instruction that follows has somewhere to land. This is not about leaving students stranded. It is about priming the brain to receive new learning. There is a memory research term for what happens here: the Generation Effect. When students generate an answer — retrieve a word, attempt a problem, construct an explanation — they remember it significantly better than when the same information is simply presented to them. The act of production is itself the act of learning. Jamie Clark’s DistillED newsletter on the Generation Effect is worth reading alongside this post — it is one of the clearest explanations of the research and its classroom implications available right now.
  • Move 3 — Limit the information given upfront. Real-world problems rarely arrive with all the relevant information pre-sorted. Give students a question and some — not all — of the information they need. Require them to identify what’s missing or what they’d need to know. That act of identifying gaps is itself higher-order thinking.
  • Move 4 — Require justification, not just answers. “What is the answer?” asks for recall. “How do you know?” asks for thinking. Build justification into the task structure — not as an add-on, but as the core requirement. A student who can get the right answer but cannot explain it has not yet learned what you think they’ve learned.
  • Move 5 — Build in a “stuck” protocol. Before students begin, name what to do when they get stuck. Three specific options: re-read the task, try a different starting point, or discuss with a partner using a sentence starter (“I think the problem is asking me to…”). This removes the habit of raising a hand the moment something feels difficult — and it signals that being stuck is expected, not a sign of failure.

What This Looks Like in HASS: Year 5 Source Analysis

A standard source analysis task gives students a primary source and asks them to identify the author, date, and one key message. That is a recall task. It sits well below the ZPD for most Year 5 students who have been doing this since Year 3.

A productive struggle version applies Moves 1, 3, and 4. Students receive two short sources on colonial settlement — a settler’s diary entry and an account from an Aboriginal perspective — with no guiding questions. The task is simply: what story are these two sources telling, and where do they disagree? From there, students must write one claim supported by evidence from both sources.

The open entry point (Move 1) means every student can begin with an observation. Limiting the guiding questions (Move 3) means students must decide what matters. Requiring a supported claim (Move 4) means the answer is not retrievable without genuine analysis. The teacher’s role shifts from answer-giver to question-asker — circulating and probing with higher-order questions that push thinking further rather than narrowing it toward a predetermined response.

For more on structuring formative checks around this kind of task, the post on formative assessment strategies covers exit ticket design in detail.


What This Looks Like in Maths: Year 3 Multiplication

A standard multiplication task: Solve 3 × 4. Solve 5 × 6. Solve 7 × 8. Students either know these or they don’t. There is no thinking available beyond retrieval — and no entry point for students who aren’t yet fluent.

A productive struggle version uses Move 1 and Move 2. The teacher displays 24 counters on the interactive whiteboard and asks: how many different ways can you arrange these into equal rows? No method has been taught yet. Students work with their own counters, recording each arrangement. From there, the class shares findings — and the teacher introduces the array and the number sentence as the language for what students already discovered.

The low floor means students working at different points of readiness can all begin. The high ceiling means a student who finds three arrangements quickly is asked: how do you know you’ve found them all? That follow-up question — requiring justification and systematic thinking — is where the stretch lives. In practice, it produces more mathematical reasoning than a worksheet of 20 isolated facts ever will.

Beyond that, notice what the task design does to the explicit teaching that follows. Because students have already struggled with the concept, the instruction has a problem to solve. It lands differently than instruction delivered cold.


Where the Gradual Release Fits

Fisher and Frey’s Gradual Release of Responsibility model — I do, We do, You do — is one of the most widely used frameworks in Australian primary schools. It is also frequently misapplied in ways that accidentally prevent productive struggle.

The problem arises when the “I do” phase is so thorough that the “You do” phase requires nothing beyond imitation. Students are not struggling — they are copying. The GRR is designed to scaffold students into independence, not to eliminate the experience of not-yet-knowing.

Used well, the GRR creates the conditions for productive struggle at the “You do” stage by deliberately withdrawing support at the right moment. The key is that the “We do” phase builds enough shared understanding that students can tolerate uncertainty — not so much that the independent task becomes a rehearsal of what they’ve already watched you do.

That calibration — knowing when to hold the scaffold and when to pull it back — is one of the most important professional judgements in teaching. Even so, it is a judgement that gets easier with practice. And it starts with task design that has stretch built in from the beginning.

Design the task for the thinking you want, not just the answer you need. Students rise to what the task demands of them — and rarely higher.

💬 Over to You — Which of the five moves are you already using, and which one are you going to try first? Or if you’ve got a task that created genuinely productive struggle in your classroom, share it below. The best ideas on this site always come from teachers who’ve already done the hard yards.

References

Bertsch, S., Pesta, B. J., Wiscott, R., & McDaniel, M. A. (2007). The generation effect: A meta-analytic review. Memory & Cognition, 35(2), 201–210. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03193441

Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In M. A. Gernsbacher, R. W. Pew, L. M. Hough, & J. R. Pomerantz (Eds.), Psychology and the real world: Essays illustrating fundamental contributions to society (pp. 56–64). Worth Publishers.

Boaler, J. (2016). Mathematical mindsets: Unleashing students’ potential through creative math, inspiring messages and innovative teaching. Jossey-Bass.

Dweck, C. S. (2006). Mindset: The new psychology of success. Random House.

Fisher, D., & Frey, N. (2014). Better learning through structured teaching: A framework for the gradual release of responsibility (2nd ed.). ASCD.

Kirschner, P. A. (2026). Offloading? No outsourcing! Retrieved from https://paulkirschner.com

Slamecka, N. J., & Graf, P. (1978). The generation effect: Delineation of a phenomenon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory, 4(6), 592–604. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-7393.4.6.592

Sweller, J. (1988). Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning. Cognitive Science, 12(2), 257–285. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog1202_4

Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Harvard University Press.